Who are “we” to say?
Firstly, that depends who “we”” are.
If “we” are vegans, it is because catfish are not vegetables.
If “we” are Jews, it is because Siluroides do not have scales, but either naked skin or bony plates. Therefore they are not kosher. Not kosher is not kosher, don’t ask me to justify it biologically. If you want to be frum, eat kosher, that’s all.
If “we” are anyone else, then the question turns on what do we mean by “catfish”.
The huge biodiversity of catfishes
There are over 3000 species of catfish in the world and they demonstrate vast diversity. From the candirù of South America which swims up people’s urethra if they urinate in the water, all the way up to giant Pangasias or Siluris species among the largest freshwater fishes of the world. Plus various marine species also.
Just to be clear about how astonishing that fact is, it means that 1 in 20 of the vertebrate species in the world is a species of catfish, in Siluriformes. There’s no other order of vertebrates like that. And the cladists have been trying to break it down until they were looking like clado-masochists, and the geneticists have been getting frenetic and still the Siluriformes is reckoned to be all the product of a single putative common ancestor.
Some species of catfish deliver toxins, some electric shocks, some like Corydoras or Otocinclus are too tiny to be of use as food, but are very popular in aquaria. Some species makes sounds, some get out of the water and walk about, some are transparent and you can see right through them.
There is one catfish fossil despite all of this, its name is Corydoras revelatus and the author has held it in the palm of his hand in the non-public area of the British Museum of Natural History thanks to the kindness of the late Dr Gordon Howes, ichthyologist.
Catfishes which are regularly eaten
The catfishes most commonly farmed as food are European catfish, Silurus glanis. As long as you have got one from sustainable sources they make good eating. I recommend “som fri”” in Russia or the Ukraine. Clearly they are a sports fish too, and in these cases we put them back, we don’t take them and eat them.
In the US it is channel cats, the Ictalurus and Ameiurus species which the song “Walking in Memphis”” references in the words “they got catfish on the table””. These are also fine eating as long as they are fished from sustainable and legitimate sources.
In the Amazon region they eat large Loricariids like Plecos. If you should be there as a tourist and are not a Vegan or kosher Jew, you might want to try one.
A lot of tropical rivers though are home to parasites that can transfer to people. And here I come onto the kind of catfish which has become more popular in supermarkets in recent years, namely Panga.
These can be farmed in particularly polluted parts of the Mekong river. I suggest you don’t make these a part of your menu, although trying them once might be ok.
This is part of a new series where I bring over, updating and re-writing where needed, the best of my answers to questions on Quora. I made a few of these in earlier years in chronological order. For now, I am moving them in the order of the number of upvotes received. These being the ones I would most regret losing. That is what they threatened me with over there for not being a Neo-Marxist. Over the course of 2022, on even numbered dates in the months, I plan to bring home to http://www.huliganov.tv as many of the best of these as I can manage. Where relevant, also to http://www.quoracy.com . I’ll be improving them, updating them, adding images. I warmly invite discussion below in each case. Enjoy!”
Original Posting Date: 22/07/2017
Question as answered: Why shouldn’t we eat catfish?
Views at the time added to HTV: 24,600
Upvotes at the time added to HTV: 20
Comments at time added: 2
2 thoughts on “Why shouldn’t we eat catfish?”
If you can get points for collecting fishes in the wild and sending them off to fishkeepers in other countries and you get to look for them in a VR world with an Oculus Rift on your head, then I imagine it would be no worse than the others. Just doing it in an Amazon setting avoiding wild animal attacks, candiru, piranhas, boas and jaguars, not to say a primitive hostile tribe who is allowed to shoot you with curare-laden darts but you’re not allowed to shoot back, all this could be quite a good theme I think. I’ll mention it to my daughter, who is learning how to do these things at University.
Fascinating stuff. One of the joys of living is the huge variety of life forms that this planet offers. I suppose just the study of fish variety and behaviour alone could take a lifetime. Perhaps ichthyology (and all of the other “…ologys” ) could form the basis of a new computer game for kids. If they really must spend so much of their time playing them it would enable them to learn more about life, rather than the dealing out of death that many of the games seem to offer in one form or another. I expect the response would likely be …….. “Oh dad that’s boring”. Sorry youngsters it’s just a thought.